Maillard, Caramelisation and Flavour Balance
Programme 9 · 50 min
Learning goals
- Know the difference between Maillard and caramelisation
- Balance salt, acid, fat, sweetness and bitterness
- Use umami synergy
- Correct a dish by tasting
Theory
Most of the deep, roasted aromas of cooked food come from two reactions. The Maillard reaction is the reaction of sugars with amino acids (the building blocks of proteins) under heat: bread crust, seared meat, roasted coffee. Caramelisation is simply the breakdown of sugar by heat: caramel, part of the flavour of slow-cooked onion. Flavour balance is knowing how salt, acid, fat, sweetness, bitterness and umami affect one another.
Technique and the science behind it
Maillard speeds up markedly once the surface passes about 140°C; while there is moisture, the temperature stays at 100°C. The reaction speeds up as the environment becomes more alkaline: a pinch of bicarbonate of soda makes onions brown faster. Sucrose caramelises at about 160–170°C; fructose takes on colour at a lower temperature. When glutamate (tomato, cheese, soy) and inosinate (meat, fish, dried fish) are used together, the perception of umami is much stronger than from either alone (synergy). Salt suppresses bitterness, acid increases the perception of saltiness, and fat carries aroma.
Step by step
- Slice one onion thinly and cook it in butter over low heat for 40–50 min, stirring, until a deep caramel colour. Sauté the other over high heat for 8–10 min. Note the difference in taste and colour.
- Dry caramel: melt the sugar in a heavy-based pan without stirring; swirl the pan until it reaches an amber colour (160–180°C).
- Tasting: divide the plain tomato soup between four bowls. Add salt to one, lemon to one, olive oil to one, and Parmesan or soy to one. Compare each with the plain soup.
- Order of correction: first salt (it wakes the dish up), then acid (brightness), then fat (roundness), and if needed, sweetness (it softens bitterness and acidity).
- Balance an over-salty dish with acid and fat; an over-sour one with sweetness and fat; an over-bitter one with salt and sweetness.
Critical temperatures and measurements
- Maillard: ~140°C and above at the surface
- Sucrose caramelisation: ~160–170°C; dark caramel around 180°C
- Caramelised onion: 40–50 min over low heat
Safety
- Hot caramel sticks to the skin and causes deep burns; stand back when adding water or cream to caramel and use a long-handled spoon.
- Burnt caramel is bitter; do not go above 190°C.
Common mistakes
- The onion burnt instead of caramelising: The heat was too high; it needs low heat and patience, and if necessary a spoonful of water.
- The caramel crystallised: Sugar crystals from the sides got mixed in; wipe the side of the pan with a wet brush and do not stir.
- The dish tastes "flat": Most often it lacks salt or acid; try salt first, then lemon.
Professional tips
- Browned butter (beurre noisette) gives desserts and vegetables a nutty depth.
- A drop of fish sauce or anchovy adds umami to meat dishes without a fishy taste.
- Use a clean spoon every time you taste.
Practice exercise
Taste the same tomato soup with four different corrections (salt, acid, fat, umami) and score each from 1 to 5. Find the most balanced combination and write it on the recipe card.