Cooking Rice: Turkish Pilaf and Risotto
Programme 6 · 60 min
Learning goals
- Understand the difference between a pilaf with separate grains and a creamy risotto
- Choose the rice variety according to the purpose
- Apply steaming off the heat and mantecatura
Theory
Rice contains two kinds of starch: amylose and amylopectin. In Turkish pilaf the aim is for every grain to be separate and buttery; for this reason the surface starch is washed away and the rice is steamed off the heat without stirring. In risotto the aim is for the centre of the grains to stay slightly firm (al dente) while the surface starch passes into the stock to form a creamy sauce; for this reason the rice is not washed and is stirred constantly.
Technique and the science behind it
Starch absorbs water and swells above about 60–70°C (gelatinisation). Short-grain rice with a high proportion of amylopectin (arborio, carnaroli) gives a creamy texture; baldo is also starchy, but when washed and soaked it gives a pilaf with separate grains. Resting after cooking lets the water on the outside of the grain spread inwards; this is why pilaf is steamed off the heat.
Step by step
- Pilaf: soak the rice in warm salted water for 20–30 min, wash until the water runs clear and drain.
- Heat the butter and oil and fry the rice for 2–3 min until the grains turn translucent and no longer stick together.
- Add the boiling stock and salt. Stir once, and when it boils, put the lid on and cook over the lowest heat for 15–17 min until the liquid is absorbed.
- Take off the heat, put a paper towel between the lid and the pan, and steam off the heat for 10–15 min. Fluff with a fork.
- Risotto: sweat the shallot in butter without colouring, add the unwashed rice and toast for 2–3 min (tostatura).
- Add the wine and stir until it evaporates.
- Add the hot stock a ladleful at a time; when each ladleful is almost absorbed, add the next, stirring constantly. 16–18 min in total.
- Take off the heat, add the cold butter cubes and grated Parmesan and beat vigorously (mantecatura). The consistency should spread across the plate like a wave (all'onda). Rest for 1 min and serve.
Critical temperatures and measurements
- Baldo pilaf: rice:liquid about 1:1.5 (less liquid for soaked rice); cook 15–17 min, steam 10–15 min
- Risotto: rice:stock about 1:3.5–4; cook 16–18 min
- Starch gelatinisation: ~60–70°C
Safety
- Cooked rice should not be left at room temperature for long (Bacillus cereus); cool it quickly and eat it within 1 day.
Common mistakes
- The pilaf turned mushy: Too much water or it was stirred; reduce the liquid and cook without lifting the lid.
- The pilaf caught on the bottom: The heat was too high; cook over the lowest heat and use a heat diffuser.
- The risotto is sticky and heavy: It was overcooked, or the butter and cheese were added over the heat; take it off the heat when the grain still has a slight bite.
- The risotto grains are hard: The stock was added cold or the time was too short; keep the stock hot.
Professional tips
- If the liquid for the pilaf is stock, adjust the salt to the salt in the stock.
- For risotto, the stock should always be at a gentle simmer in the pan next to it.
- Carnaroli is more forgiving than arborio in risotto; it holds its shape better.
Practice exercise
Make two pilafs from the same rice: one washed and soaked, the other cooked directly. Compare the separation of the grains and the texture. Then taste a risotto at the 14th, 17th and 20th minute and note how the texture changes.