Meat Doneness, Collagen and Resting
Programme 4 · 60 min
Learning goals
- Define doneness by internal temperature
- Allow for carryover heat
- Know which cuts cook quickly and which cook slowly
- Rest and carve meat correctly
Theory
Meat is made up of muscle fibres, connective tissue (collagen) and fat. Muscles that work hard (shin, cheek, brisket) are rich in collagen: they need slow, moist cooking. Muscles that work little (fillet, sirloin, striploin) are tender: they are cooked quickly over high heat and left pink. The right way to cook depends on the cut.
Technique and the science behind it
Muscle proteins change at different temperatures: myosin begins to coagulate at about 50°C (the meat firms up), and actin contracts above about 66°C and squeezes the juices out (the meat dries). Collagen shrinks at around 60°C, but it turns into gelatine only when held above 70°C for a long time; this is why shin becomes tender after 3 hr. After the meat comes off the heat, the heat at the surface continues to move inwards (carryover heat); in large joints the internal temperature rises by a further 3–5°C. Resting lets the fibres relax and redistribute the juices.
Step by step
- Insert the thermometer into the exact centre of the thickest part of the meat, without touching the bone.
- Take the meat off the heat 3–5°C below the target doneness (carryover heat).
- For steak: dry it, season it and sear each side for 2–3 min in a hot pan, pressing the fat edge against the pan to render it and make it crisp.
- Bring thick cuts up to the target temperature in the oven (e.g. 180°C) or over low heat.
- Rest: steak 5–10 min, a large roast 15–20 min; on a wire rack, loosely covered.
- Find the direction of the grain and carve the meat across the fibres; shortening the fibres makes the meat feel tender.
- Braise: sear the shin or cheek, cover it halfway with liquid and cook with a lid in a 150–160°C oven, or over low heat, for 2.5–3.5 hr until a knife goes in easily.
Critical temperatures and measurements
- Beef/lamb: rare 50–52°C · medium-rare 54–57°C · medium 60–63°C · medium-well 65–68°C · well done 70°C+
- Carryover heat: +3–5°C
- Collagen turning into gelatine: 70°C+ for a long time
- Safe internal temperature for poultry: 74°C
- Resting: steak 5–10 min, roast 15–20 min
Safety
- Minced meat and products made from it must always be cooked to an internal temperature of 71°C; bacteria from the surface have been carried inside by the mincing.
- Chicken and turkey are never left pink (except for sous-vide pasteurisation; see the Sous-vide lesson).
- Clean the thermometer after every reading.
Common mistakes
- A lot of liquid ran onto the plate when carved: It was not rested; leave it for 5–10 min.
- The steak formed a grey ring: It stayed too long over very high heat; reverse-sear thick cuts (low heat first, then sear).
- The shin stayed tough: It has not cooked long enough; the collagen has not yet turned into gelatine, so extend the time.
- The meat is rubbery: It was cut parallel to the fibres; cut across them.
Professional tips
- Reverse sear: a thick steak is first brought to 10°C below the target in a 110–120°C oven, then seared in a very hot pan; this gives an even pinkness from edge to edge.
- On meat on the bone, the part nearest the bone cooks more slowly.
- Salting the night before (dry brining) dries the surface and gives a better crust.
Practice exercise
Cut a sirloin steak in two. Cook one with a classic sear and the other with a reverse sear. Take both off the heat at 55°C, rest them, cut them through the middle, and compare the photos of the cross-sections and the internal temperature after resting.