
Mini Pan Bagnat 2.0
A French meze. Takes 1 hr 26 min, Makes 24. Difficulty: professional.
At a glance
- Total time
- 1 hr 26 min
- Serves
- Makes 24
- Difficulty
- Professional
- Cuisine
- French cuisine
- Dish type
- Meze
- Allergens
- Gluten, Milk, Eggs, Fish, Mustard, Sulphites
Ingredients
- Gougère shells (24 × 15 g, 3 cm mounds, about 4.5 cm once baked, about 370 g of dough in total): 125 ml water
- 55 g butter
- 1/4 tsp salt
- 75 g plain flour
- 2 eggs (about 100 g)
- 30 g grated Gruyère
- 15 g pitted black olives (dried, 1 mm dice)
Glaze
- 1 egg yolk and 1 tsp water. Confit tuna (24 × 8 g, about 200 g): 250 g fresh tuna fillet (2.5 cm thick, of a quality that can be eaten raw)
- 500 ml olive oil
- 1 thyme sprig
- 1 strip of lemon zest
- 1 tsp salt. Anchovy aioli (24 × 3 g, about 72 g): 60 g Aioli (Basics)
- 4 salted anchovy fillets (rinsed of salt, crushed in a mortar)
- 1 tsp lemon juice. Egg yolk cream (24 × 3.5 g, about 85 g): 3 eggs (boiled for 9 min, yolks only)
- 2 tbsp confit oil
- 1 tsp Homemade Dijon-Style Mustard (Basics)
- 1 tsp lemon juice
- 1/4 tsp salt. Marinated tomato (24 × 6 g, about 145 g): 70 g firm tomatoes (3 mm dice, deseeded)
- 10 g red onion (2 mm dice)
- 40 g finely chopped boiled egg whites
- 2 tsp wine vinegar
- 2 tsp confit oil
- 1/4 tsp salt
To finish
- 20 g Herb Oils (Basics, basil)
- 1 tsp fleur de sel
Equipment
- wire rack
Equipment
- Saucepan
- Wooden spoon / spatula
- Piping bag
- Piping nozzles
- Baking tray
- Baking paper
- Oven
- Pastry brush
- Probe thermometer
- Chef's knife
- Mixing bowls
- Pestle and mortar
- Silicone spatula
Method
- Cook the choux pastry: Preheat the oven to 200°C. Bring the water, butter and salt to the boil in a pan over medium heat, and once the butter has melted completely, reduce the heat and add the flour in one go. Stir with a wooden spoon for 2 min, until the dough comes together in one piece and leaves a thin film on the bottom of the pan. The starch in the flour gelatinises here and traps the steam that the egg will carry. Transfer the dough to a bowl and cool for 3 min, until below 60°C, as hot dough cooks the egg (~12 min)
- Add the eggs and flavourings: Whisk the eggs and add to the dough in two additions, beating vigorously with a wooden spoon for 2 min each time. The dough should drop slowly from the spoon in a V shape, and if it is too runny the shells collapse. Stir in the Gruyère and olive pieces. The cheese and olives add a savoury depth to the shell and carry the olive character of pan bagnat (~6 min)
- Pipe and brush: Fill a piping bag fitted with a 1 cm plain nozzle with the dough. Pipe 24 mounds, 3 cm across and 2 cm high (15 g each), onto a 30×40 cm tray lined with baking paper, in 4 columns × 6 rows, 4 cm apart, as the shells grow to about 4.5 cm when baked. Brush with the yolk and water mixture and flatten the tips of the mounds by pressing with the tip of a fork. A flattened tip stops the shell tilting to one side as it rises (~8 min)
- Bake: Put the tray on the middle shelf and bake at 200°C for 12 min without opening the door, then reduce the heat to 170°C and bake for another 15 min, until the shells are deep golden and feel light in the hand. Opening the oven door early lets the steam escape and the shells collapse. Turn off the oven, prop the door ajar and dry the shells for 3 min so that the insides do not stay damp (~28 min)
- Confit the tuna: Salt the tuna with the salt and lemon zest for 10 min. Heat the olive oil and thyme sprig to 65°C in a small, narrow pan (14 cm), checking with a thermometer. Lower the tuna into the oil and hold at 65°C for 12 min, until the internal temperature reaches 58°C (medium, pink). Low heat keeps the protein silky without making it rubbery. Remove, cool for 8 min and flake into 6 mm pieces with a fork. Make this while the shells bake
- Make the creams: Mash the egg yolks in a mortar or bowl and mix with the confit oil, mustard, lemon juice and salt with a spatula into a smooth cream, then transfer to a piping bag. Mash the anchovy fillets in the mortar, mix with the Aioli and lemon juice and transfer to a separate bag. Finely chop the whites and mix with the tomato, onion, vinegar, confit oil and salt. Salt draws the juice out of the tomato, and the vinegar gives the marinade its sharpness. These are also made while the shells bake
- Cool and cut the lids: Take the shells off the tray and cool completely on a wire rack for 10 min. Cut the top third off each shell as a lid with a chef's knife. A hot shell melts the oil in the filling and lets it leak, whereas a cold shell holds the filling (~10 min)
- Fill: Pipe 3.5 g egg yolk cream into each shell first, then add 8 g confit tuna and 6 g marinated tomato, put 3 g anchovy aioli on the very top and replace the lid. The order of the layers matters: the cream stops the tuna slipping, while the tomato adds moisture between the tuna and the aioli. The filling should stand 3 mm proud of the shell so that it can be seen (~16 min)
- Plate: Place 2 gougères side by side on a flat ceramic plate, drizzle 1 g basil oil over the lids and add a pinch of fleur de sel. The shell should be thin and crisp, and the tuna between lukewarm and cold. Serve within 20 min, as shells left waiting turn soggy (~6 min)
Chef's note
The shells are served at room temperature and the filling cold. Allow 2 per person, 120 people × 2 = 240 pieces. Because the recipe makes 24, the multiplier is 240/24 = 10, or 10.5 with 5% waste (790 g flour, 580 g butter, 2.63 kg fresh tuna, 5.3 litres olive oil (for the confit, 2.7 litres is enough if it is drained and reused for the second batch), 320 g Gruyère, 63 eggs (dough, glaze and cream)). Bake the shells 1 day ahead and store in a lidded box, then refresh at 160°C for 4 min at service. Prepare the confit tuna, aioli and creams 1 day ahead, and fill no more than 30 min before serving. Oven capacity: 24 shells fit on a 30×40 cm tray, so 10.5 batches need 11 trays, which is 6 rounds in a 2-shelf oven (about 3 hr), which is why the shells are baked the day before. Keep the tuna in the cold chain below 4°C and do not leave it at room temperature for more than 2 hr. The classic components of Pan Bagnat (tuna, anchovies, egg, tomato, olives, basil) are kept, with a cheesy choux shell in place of the bread. Tinned tuna in olive oil can be used instead of fresh tuna (2 tins, 24 × 8 g).
Frequently asked questions
- Why do the gougere shells collapse while baking?
- Opening the oven door too early lets the steam out and collapses the shells. Bake them at 200°C for 12 minutes without opening the door, then finish at 170°C.
- Why is the egg not added to the choux pastry straight away?
- Hot dough cooks the egg. Cool the dough in the bowl until it drops below 60°C, then add the egg in two batches.
- Why is the tuna confit cooked at 65°C?
- The low heat keeps the protein silky without turning it rubbery. Cook the tuna in olive oil at 65°C until the internal temperature reaches 58°C.
Nice Tuna Sandwich Rolls, 6.5 cm2 hr 59 min · Meze
Tuna Tartare, Potato Rösti Disc, Quail's Egg55 min · Starter
Duck Rillettes, Fig Jam, Crunchy Crostini, Pickle Salad1 hr 30 min · Starter
Prawns, Garlic Confit Aioli, Charred Tomatoes, Fennel Salad35 min · Starter
Beetroot Carpaccio, Goat's Cheese Mousse, Walnuts1 hr · Starter
Honey Mustard Chicken, Potato Gratin, Asparagus1 hr 30 min · Main course
Beef Fillet, Red Wine Sauce, Pommes Purée1 hr 10 min · Main course