
Paraguayan Fish and Cheese Soup Pira Caldo
A Paraguayan soup. Takes 1 hr 5 min, Serves 4. Difficulty: medium.
At a glance
- Total time
- 1 hr 5 min
- Serves
- Serves 4
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Cuisine
- Paraguayan cuisine
- Dish type
- Soup
- Diet
- Gluten-free
- Allergens
- Milk, Fish
Ingredients
Fish
- 1 kg whole catfish (in place of surubí, or 800 g mixed sea bass and whiting)
Fumet
- head
- bones and skin of the fish
- 1.2 litres water
- 1 bay leaf
- 1/2 onion
Soup
- 3 tbsp sunflower oil
- 1 onion (finely chopped)
- 1 red pepper (small dice)
- 1 green pepper (small dice)
- 2 tomatoes (grated)
- 2 garlic cloves (chopped)
- 1 tsp dried oregano
- 1.5 tsp salt
- 1/2 tsp black pepper
- 400 ml milk
- 150 g fresh cheese (100 g fresh Turkish semi-hard cheese and 50 g white cheese, crumbled; in place of queso Paraguay)
To finish
- 2 tbsp finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
- 2 spring onions (chopped)
Equipment
- Chopping board
- Filleting knife
- Chef's knife
- Plating tweezers
- Saucepan
- Ladle
- Fine sieve / chinois
- Heavy-based saucepan
- Probe thermometer (optional)
Method
- Clean the fish: Cut off the head of the fish with a filleting knife on a chopping board, take off two fillets along the backbone and remove the skin. Pull out the pin bones with tweezers. Cut the flesh into 4 cm pieces and keep in the fridge. Set aside the head, bones and skin for the fumet. Takes 12 min
- Make the fumet: Put the head, bones and skin in a saucepan with the cold water and add the bay leaf and half onion. When it boils, skim off the scum with a ladle and simmer over a low heat for 20 min. Fish bones turn bitter if cooked for long, so 20 min is enough. Strain through a fine sieve. About 1 litre of liquid should remain
- Chop the vegetables: While the fumet cooks, finely chop the onion, peppers and garlic with a chef's knife on a chopping board and grate the tomatoes
- Start the sofrito: Heat the oil in a heavy-based saucepan over a medium heat, soften the onion and peppers for 7 min, then add the garlic and stir for 1 min. Add the tomatoes and oregano and cook for 2 min. In Paraguay this oily vegetable base carries the colour and flavour of the soup
- Add the fumet: Pour the strained fumet over the sofrito, add the salt and pepper, bring to the boil and cook for 5 min. Takes 8 min in total
- Cook the fish: Add the fish pieces, lower the heat and cook for 8 min so the soup barely trembles. If it boils fast, the fish falls apart. The internal temperature at the thickest part of the pieces should reach 63°C. If in doubt, check with a probe thermometer
- Stir in the milk and cheese: Add the milk and heat the soup for 2-3 min without boiling. Just before taking it off the heat, scatter in the cheese and wait 1 min for it to soften and start to turn stringy. A milky soup splits if it boils
- Serve: Ladle the fish pieces into deep bowls first, then fill with the soup. Scatter over the parsley and spring onion and serve hot with sopa paraguaya or chipa guasu
Chef's note
The word pira in the name of pira caldo is said to mean "fish" in Guaraní. It is the food of the fishermen along the Paraguay and Paraná rivers and is described as a soup that restores your strength. The original recipe uses surubí or other freshwater catfish; in Türkiye wels catfish gives the closest texture. As queso Paraguay is unavailable, a mix of fresh semi-hard cheese and white cheese is used.
Frequently asked questions
- Why does a milky fish soup split?
- A soup with milk splits if it boils. After the milk goes in, heat the soup without letting it boil.
- How do I stop the fish falling apart in the soup?
- The fish breaks up if it boils fast. Cook the soup on a low heat so it barely trembles.
- Why isn't the fish fumet cooked for long?
- Fish bones turn bitter when cooked for long, so the fumet is stopped at 20 minutes. Then strain it through a fine sieve.
Cheese and Onion Cornbread1 hr 40 min · Bread & pastry
Chicken Soup with Cornmeal Dumplings1 hr 45 min · Soup
Cassava Cheese Bread with Aniseed1 hr 20 min · Bread & pastry
Fresh Corn and Cheese Bake1 hr 30 min · Side dish
Cassava Starch and Cheese Pancake1 hr 5 min · Bread & pastry
Pounded Beef and Rice Soup1 hr 5 min · Soup